Craigslist can be a great place to find or sell a used car—but it’s also home to some of the most creative and convincing scams online. Whether you’re buying or selling, knowing the most common fraud tactics is your best defense. In this article, we break down the top 5 Craigslist car scams you need to know—and exactly how to avoid them.
1. The Overpayment Scam (Seller Targeted)
How it works: A “buyer” sends a cashier’s check or money order for more than the agreed price. They then ask the seller to wire back the difference, claiming it’s for shipping or taxes.
What really happens: The original check bounces days later—and you’re out the money you refunded.
How to avoid it:
- Never accept overpayments from strangers
- Verify any check at the issuing bank before handing over the vehicle
- Only accept cash or verified payments in person
2. The Fake eBay Motors Scam (Buyer Targeted)
How it works: A Craigslist seller claims the transaction will be processed “safely” through eBay Motors. You’ll receive a professional-looking email with instructions to send money via gift cards or wire.
What really happens: The email is fake, the listing is fake, and once you send the money—it’s gone.
How to avoid it:
- eBay Motors does not handle transactions from Craigslist
- Never send payment outside trusted platforms
- Always verify listings on eBay directly—not through email links
3. The VIN Report Scam
How it works: A “buyer” asks the seller to purchase a VIN report from a specific (usually fake) website before proceeding with the sale.
What really happens: The VIN site is a scam that steals your credit card info or charges you for a worthless report.
How to avoid it:
4. The Shipping Company Scam
How it works: The scammer claims they’re buying the car remotely and will send a shipping company to pick it up. They ask you to pay the “shipping agent” up front—often from the overpayment amount.
What really happens: The shipping company doesn’t exist. You’re sending money directly to the scammer or their partner.
How to avoid it:
- Don’t deal with third-party shipping agents unless you initiate the transaction
- Insist on meeting the buyer in person
5. The Identity Theft Scam (Buyer & Seller)
How it works: The scammer asks for personal information—like your driver’s license, VIN, or address—claiming it’s needed for insurance or verification. In some cases, they ask you to fill out fake “DMV forms.”
What really happens: Your information is used for identity theft, fraudulent loans, or resale scams.
How to avoid it:
- Never share personal info before verifying the buyer/seller
- Avoid filling out online forms or links from unknown sources
- Meet in public and exchange info only at the point of sale
Final Tips: How to Stay Safe
- Meet in police-monitored public areas
- Use secure, verifiable payment methods
- Verify all documents (title, VIN, registration)
- Walk away if anything feels rushed or suspicious
Scams thrive on urgency, pressure, and confusion. Take your time, ask questions, and trust your instincts.
Conclusion: Know the Scams. Stop the Scams.
Craigslist car scams aren’t going away—but by staying informed and alert, you can outsmart the fraudsters. Share this list with anyone you know who’s buying or selling a car online, and help create a safer marketplace for everyone.